RSS

Save Thousands or Sacrifice Service? The Low Commission Agent Debate

Save Thousands or Sacrifice Service? The Low Commission Agent Debate

Introduction

Selling your home is a major financial decision, and maximizing your profit while minimizing costs is crucial. One way to cut expenses is by hiring a low commission real estate agent. These agents charge lower fees than traditional ones, but does that mean sacrificing quality service?

This blog explores the advantages and drawbacks of working with low commission agents, compares them to traditional agents, and helps determine if they’re the right choice for your home sale.

What’s the Average Real Estate Commission?

Traditional real estate commissions typically range from 4% to 6% of the home's sale price, split between the listing and buyer’s agents. However, commission structures are evolving, with some sellers negotiating fees as low as 1% to 3%. Low commission agents may offer rates from 1% to 1.5% to attract cost-conscious sellers.

What Is a Low Commission Real Estate Agent?

A low commission agent charges a reduced fee for listing services, often between 1% and 1.5%. While the savings can be substantial, lower costs may come with trade-offs in marketing, negotiation, and service quality.

Are Low Commission Real Estate Agents Reputable?

These agents must meet the same licensing and training standards as traditional agents. Many are experienced professionals, though their level of service can vary. Some excel in high-volume transactions, while others may lack the time for personalized client support.

Risks of Using a Low Commission Real Estate Agent

1. Limited Service and Support

Low commission agents often handle multiple clients at once, leading to reduced personal attention, slower responses, and minimal hands-on guidance.

2. Lower Sale Price Potential

A full-service agent markets aggressively, prices strategically, and negotiates effectively. A low commission agent may offer limited marketing, resulting in a lower final sale price.

3. Dual Agency Conflicts

Some low commission agents act as dual agents, representing both the buyer and seller, which can lead to conflicts of interest.

4. Reduced Marketing Exposure

Traditional agents invest in professional photos, virtual tours, and targeted advertising. A discount agent may cut corners, limiting buyer interest and possibly affecting your final sale price.

5. Fewer Showings Due to Buyer Agent Commission Cuts

Agents may be less inclined to show homes that offer reduced buyer’s agent commissions, reducing potential offers.

6. Higher Risk of Sale Falling Through

With multiple clients to manage, low commission agents may be less responsive in critical deal negotiations, inspections, or repair requests.

Alternative Home Sale Options

1. For Sale By Owner (FSBO)

Selling your home yourself eliminates agent fees but requires significant effort. FSBO homes often sell for less and take longer to close.

2. Cash Buyers and iBuyer Services

Companies that buy homes for cash offer quick sales, but often below market value. This option suits those prioritizing speed over profit.

3. Traditional Full-Service Real Estate Agent

Full-service agents provide expert pricing strategies, broad market exposure, and strong negotiation skills, typically leading to a higher final sale price.

What Can You Expect from a Traditional Real Estate Agent?

A full-service agent provides:

  • Professional marketing (high-quality photos, virtual tours, and staging)

  • Competitive pricing strategies

  • A broad buyer network and targeted advertising

  • Skilled negotiation for higher profits

  • End-to-end transaction management

How to Check If a Low Commission Agent Is Reputable

  • Research Reviews and Testimonials: Look for online feedback from past clients.

  • Verify Licensing and Credentials: Check your state’s real estate board.

  • Ask About Services and Marketing: Ensure their offerings align with your expectations.

  • Review Their Track Record: Ask about past sales and average time on market.

Conclusion: Should You Use a Low Commission Real Estate Agent?

A low commission agent may be a smart choice if you’re selling in a hot market, have a highly desirable home, and are comfortable with a hands-off approach. However, if maximizing your home’s sale price and receiving full-service support is a priority, a traditional agent is often the better investment.

Before deciding, weigh the savings against the potential risks. If service quality, negotiation expertise, and strong marketing matter to you, a full-service agent may offer the best return on investment.

The trademarks REALTOR®, REALTORS®, and the REALTOR® logo are controlled by The Canadian Real Estate Association (CREA) and identify real estate professionals who are member’s of CREA. The trademarks MLS®, Multiple Listing Service® and the associated logos are owned by CREA and identify the quality of services provided by real estate professionals who are members of CREA. Used under license.