Economic uncertainty is currently gripping Canada and the United States, particularly within the real estate sector. Investors and homebuyers who are making million-dollar or multi-million-dollar transactions require stability and certainty. However, with policy shifts and unpredictable economic events, the real estate market is experiencing significant turbulence. Every time there is a shift in government policy or economic conditions, the market tends to freeze.
If we examine the latest data from Vancouver and Toronto, the two largest real estate markets in Canada, we see a sharp decline in housing activity, particularly on the sales side. Vancouver home sales have declined by 11% year over year. While this might not seem drastic at first glance, zooming out reveals a concerning trend. February 2024 was one of the slowest months for sales in the last 25 years, trailing only behind 2019, 2013, and 2009. Inventory is beginning to build, but primarily in specific sectors—most notably, the condo market.
A Surge in Condo Listings and Investor Sell-Offs
New listings hit record highs in January and February, particularly in the condo market. Many investors are exiting due to years of negative cash flow, high mortgage rates, and softening rental conditions. Vacancies are increasing, and units are taking longer to rent, leading many investors to cut their losses. However, as they attempt to sell, they face an illiquid market due to an inventory surge.
Suburban markets are witnessing significant shifts as well. Since 2015, suburban condo prices in Greater Vancouver, particularly in the Fraser Valley, have doubled. The pandemic fueled demand as remote work became more common, pushing buyers further from city centers. However, as interest rates increased, these local end-user markets—often more sensitive to financial fluctuations—are seeing inventory pile up. Standing inventory in the Fraser Valley’s condo market is now at an all-time high. Historically, when inventory surges to such levels, prices tend to fall.
The Greater Toronto Area (GTA) is experiencing similar issues. Seasonally adjusted home sales declined by 28% on a month-over-month basis, marking the steepest drop since the pandemic and the global financial crisis. The condo segment, particularly among investors, is facing the most challenges. Pre-construction condo sales in 2024 hit a 30-year low. If developers cannot pre-sell units, they simply do not build, leading to a sharp drop in future housing supply.
Government Intervention and Pre-Construction Market Struggles
The British Columbia government recently extended the pre-construction sales period from 12 months to 18 months to allow developers more time to secure financing. This policy shift acknowledges the challenges in the pre-construction market, where projects are struggling to get off the ground. A similar trend is emerging in the GTA, where developers are also struggling to sell pre-construction units, further impacting future housing supply.
Despite the slowing construction market, the federal government is fast-tracking 6,000 undocumented construction workers. This move is ill-timed, as housing starts are already declining rapidly. The demand for construction workers was high during the peak of the market in 2020-2022, but with housing starts now plummeting, the industry will soon face an oversupply of labor. Many construction workers may struggle to find work as current projects wrap up and fewer new developments begin.
Tax Policies and Housing Market Challenges
In an effort to address budget deficits, the British Columbia government has increased the speculation and vacancy tax from 2% to 3% for foreign owners and from 0.5% to 1% for Canadian residents. This tax primarily affects secondary homeowners who use properties as vacation homes. The unintended consequence is that these taxes may discourage investment in housing markets where additional supply is already limited.
Adding to the complexity, the BC government has mandated multiplex housing across the province to increase density. However, utility companies, particularly BC Hydro, are struggling to meet the demand for new developments. Multiplex units require significant electrical infrastructure, including large transformers (PMTs), which take about 12 months for approval. Developers face high holding costs due to these delays, reducing the feasibility of these projects. If natural gas heating were permitted, many of these delays could be avoided, but current policies mandate electric-only heating, further complicating new developments.
The Road Ahead for Real Estate
The Canadian real estate market is at a critical juncture. Uncertainty surrounding economic policies, interest rates, and government intervention is creating an environment where investors and homebuyers are hesitant to act. The data suggests that condo markets, particularly in suburban areas, are at the highest risk of price declines due to rising inventory and decreasing demand. Meanwhile, pre-construction markets are stagnating, which will impact housing supply in the coming years.
Policymakers must carefully consider the timing and implications of their decisions. Fast-tracking construction workers during a market downturn, increasing taxes on secondary homes, and imposing rigid development regulations could exacerbate the current slowdown. Market participants must navigate these challenges with caution, keeping an eye on economic trends and policy changes that could impact their investments.
As the situation continues to evolve, it is essential to monitor housing activity, interest rate trends, and government policies. The coming months will be critical in determining whether the market stabilizes or if further turbulence lies ahead. Investors and homebuyers should prepare for continued uncertainty and make informed decisions based on the latest market data.